Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs Database Language

Leave a Comment / Database Languages / By piembsystech

ech.com/graphql-language/">GraphQL applications. This guide dives deep into how Apollo Client streamlines communication with your GraphQL APIs, enabling fast, flexible, and scalable data interactions. Whether you’re working with React, Angular, or Vue, you’ll learn how to seamlessly integrate Apollo Client to manage queries, caching, and real-time updates with ease. From setting up your client to handling advanced features like pagination and optimistic UI, we’ll walk you through practical strategies that boost performance and developer productivity. Ideal for new builds or existing projects, this guide helps you unlock the full potential of GraphQL on the client side.

Introduction to Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database Integration

Building modern web applications demands a seamless connection between the frontend and backend and that’s exactly where Apollo Client shines. In this guide, we’ll explore how Apollo Client serves as a powerful tool for interacting with GraphQL APIs while efficiently managing data fetched from databases like PostgreSQL, MySQL, and others. Whether you’re creating a new project or enhancing an existing one, understanding how to integrate Apollo Client with your API and database setup is key to delivering fast, responsive, and scalable applications. From setting up queries and mutations to handling caching and error management, this introduction will help you unlock the full potential of Apollo Client in your GraphQL-powered stack.

What is the role of Apollo Client in working with GraphQL APIs and Database?

Apollo Client is a powerful JavaScript library that acts as a bridge between your frontend application and GraphQL APIs. Its primary role is to facilitate efficient data fetching, caching, and state management when interacting with GraphQL endpoints, which themselves serve as a layer to access databases like PostgreSQL, MySQL, or others.

Key Features of Apollo Client in working with GraphQL APIs and Database

1. Efficient Data Fetching: Apollo Client enables precise and efficient data fetching by allowing you to write GraphQL queries that request only the data your application needs. This minimizes over-fetching and under-fetching, improving the speed and performance of your app. Instead of multiple REST calls, a single query can retrieve nested, related data in one request. This tight integration with GraphQL APIs ensures seamless communication with the database through the server layer.
2. Intelligent Caching: One of Apollo Client’s most powerful features is its built-in caching mechanism. It stores query results locally, reducing redundant network requests for the same data. This caching improves app responsiveness and decreases server load. The cache is normalized, meaning data is stored by unique identifiers, allowing Apollo to automatically update UI components when data changes, ensuring consistency across the application.
3. State Management: Apollo Client doubles as a state management tool, managing both remote data from GraphQL APIs and local client state. This reduces the need for separate state management libraries like Redux or MobX. You can seamlessly combine server data with local UI state within the Apollo cache, streamlining development and keeping your app’s data handling simpler and more maintainable.
4. Real-time Updates with Subscriptions: Apollo Client supports GraphQL subscriptions, which enable real-time data updates pushed from the server to the client. This is essential for building live features like notifications, chats, or dashboards. Subscriptions keep your UI in sync with the database changes without polling, providing a smoother, more dynamic user experience in applications that require real-time interactivity.
5. Optimistic UI and Mutation Handling: When updating data, Apollo Client supports optimistic UI updates, which immediately reflect changes on the frontend before the server confirms the mutation. This enhances user experience by making the app feel faster and more responsive. Apollo also provides robust tools for handling mutation results and errors, ensuring data consistency between the client UI and the database via the GraphQL API.
6. Developer Tools and Ecosystem: Apollo Client offers excellent developer tools, including browser extensions for inspecting queries, mutations, and cache state in real time. These tools make debugging and optimizing GraphQL operations easier. Coupled with a rich ecosystem of plugins and integrations for frameworks like React, Angular, and Vue, Apollo Client provides a comprehensive environment that accelerates development and maintenance of GraphQL applications connected to databases.
7. Flexible Query Management: Apollo Client provides flexible ways to manage queries, including lazy queries, polling, and query batching. Lazy queries allow you to delay a query until a specific event occurs, optimizing network usage. Polling enables periodic fetching of updated data, useful when real-time subscriptions aren’t available. Query batching combines multiple queries into a single request, reducing network overhead and improving performance, especially in complex applications with many simultaneous data needs.
8. Role-Based Access Control Support: While Apollo Client itself doesn’t enforce security, it integrates seamlessly with authentication and authorization layers in GraphQL APIs. By leveraging the context object on the server and sending authentication tokens via Apollo Client, you can implement role-based access control. This allows the client to request data appropriate for the user’s permissions, ensuring secure data access while maintaining efficient communication with the database through GraphQL.
9. Seamless Integration with Various Frontend Frameworks: Apollo Client is designed to work smoothly with popular frontend frameworks like React, Angular, and Vue. It offers dedicated libraries (e.g., @apollo/client for React) that provide hooks and components, making GraphQL queries and mutations simple and declarative within your UI code. This tight integration helps developers build interactive and performant applications with minimal boilerplate, while still leveraging powerful GraphQL and database capabilities.

Basic Query to Fetch Data

Here, Apollo Client fetches data from a GraphQL API that retrieves user information stored in a database.

import { useQuery, gql } from '@apollo/client';

const GET_USERS = gql`
  query GetUsers {
    users {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function UsersList() {
  const { loading, error, data } = useQuery(GET_USERS);

  if (loading) return <p>Loading users...</p>;
  if (error) return <p>Error fetching users!</p>;

  return (
    <ul>
      {data.users.map(user => (
        <li key={user.id}>{user.name} - {user.email}</li>
      ))}
    </ul>
  );
}

Apollo Client’s useQuery hook sends the GET_USERS GraphQL query to the server. The server queries the database for user data and returns it. Apollo Client caches this data and updates the React component automatically.

Mutations to Update Data

Apollo Client can send mutations to update the database via GraphQL APIs.

import { useMutation, gql } from '@apollo/client';
import { useState } from 'react';

const ADD_USER = gql`
  mutation AddUser($name: String!, $email: String!) {
    addUser(name: $name, email: $email) {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function AddUserForm() {
  const [name, setName] = useState('');
  const [email, setEmail] = useState('');
  const [addUser, { data, loading, error }] = useMutation(ADD_USER);

  const handleSubmit = (e) => {
    e.preventDefault();
    addUser({ variables: { name, email } });
  };

  if (loading) return <p>Adding user...</p>;
  if (error) return <p>Error adding user!</p>;

  return (
    <form onSubmit={handleSubmit}>
      <input value={name} onChange={e => setName(e.target.value)} placeholder="Name" />
      <input value={email} onChange={e => setEmail(e.target.value)} placeholder="Email" />
      <button type="submit">Add User</button>
    </form>
  );
}

The useMutation hook sends a mutation to the GraphQL API, which updates the database. Apollo Client manages the mutation lifecycle, including loading and error states.

Caching for Performance

Apollo Client caches query results to minimize repeated requests and improve app responsiveness.

// Same GET_USERS query as above

function UsersListWithCache() {
  const { loading, error, data } = useQuery(GET_USERS, {
    fetchPolicy: 'cache-first', // Default: tries cache before network
  });

  // Component UI as before...
}

By default, Apollo Client uses a normalized cache that stores query results. This example explicitly sets the fetch policy to cache-first, which prioritizes cached data over network requests, speeding up the app and reducing server load.

Handling Real-Time Data with Subscriptions

Apollo Client supports GraphQL subscriptions for real-time updates.

import { useSubscription, gql } from '@apollo/client';

const USER_ADDED = gql`
  subscription OnUserAdded {
    userAdded {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function NewUsers() {
  const { data, loading } = useSubscription(USER_ADDED);

  if (loading) return <p>Waiting for new users...</p>;

  return (
    <div>
      <h4>New User Added:</h4>
      <p>{data.userAdded.name} - {data.userAdded.email}</p>
    </div>
  );
}

The useSubscription hook listens for new user additions pushed by the server in real time. This requires the backend GraphQL server to support subscriptions, which directly reflect changes in the database to the client.

Why do we need Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database?

In modern web development, efficiently managing data flow between the frontend and backend is crucial for building fast, responsive applications. GraphQL APIs provide a flexible way to request exactly the data needed from a database, but handling these requests on the client side can quickly become complex. This is where Apollo Client comes in.

1. Simplifies Data Fetching and State Management

One of the main reasons we need Apollo Client is that it drastically simplifies the process of fetching data from GraphQL APIs. Without Apollo Client, developers would need to write a lot of boilerplate code to send queries and mutations, handle loading states, and process errors. Apollo Client provides a declarative way to manage all of this using React hooks or higher-order components, making data fetching straightforward and maintainable. Additionally, Apollo Client also acts as a state management library by caching remote data locally, reducing the need for separate state management tools like Redux. This unified approach to handling remote and local state makes developing scalable applications much easier.

2. Optimizes Performance with Intelligent Caching

Apollo Client’s built-in caching mechanism is another key reason it is essential when working with GraphQL APIs and databases. It caches the results of GraphQL queries and stores them in a normalized form, meaning data is saved based on unique identifiers. This allows Apollo Client to automatically update the UI with minimal network requests by reading from the cache whenever possible. By avoiding repeated fetches for the same data, apps built with Apollo Client experience faster load times and reduced server load. The cache also enables features like offline support and optimistic UI updates, which enhance user experience by making apps feel quicker and more responsive.

3. Enables Real-Time Functionality with Subscriptions

Modern applications increasingly require real-time updates to stay relevant and engaging. Apollo Client supports GraphQL subscriptions, which allow the client to receive live data pushed directly from the server. This is critical for features like chat apps, live notifications, or dynamic dashboards that need instant updates based on changes in the database. Subscriptions reduce the need for inefficient polling strategies by maintaining an open connection and automatically updating the UI when new data arrives. Integrating real-time data streams with Apollo Client helps maintain synchronization between the frontend and backend seamlessly.

4. Streamlines Integration Across Different Frontend Frameworks

Apollo Client is designed to be highly flexible and works well with popular frontend frameworks such as React, Angular, and Vue. It provides specialized libraries and utilities for each framework, enabling developers to write idiomatic, declarative code that integrates GraphQL queries and mutations naturally within UI components. This seamless integration means that developers don’t have to learn a completely new paradigm or rewrite their entire frontend to work with GraphQL APIs. Instead, Apollo Client bridges the gap between complex backend data and modern UI frameworks, making it easier to build interactive and dynamic web applications connected to various databases.

5. Supports Optimistic UI for Better User Experience

Apollo Client allows developers to implement optimistic UI updates, which significantly enhance user experience. When a user performs an action such as submitting a form or updating data, Apollo Client can immediately reflect this change in the UI before the server confirms the mutation. This creates the illusion of instantaneous feedback, making the application feel faster and more responsive. If the server later returns an error, Apollo Client can roll back the change seamlessly. This approach reduces perceived latency and keeps users engaged, especially in applications where speed and responsiveness are critical.

6. Handles Complex Query Management and Network Policies

Managing GraphQL queries efficiently is essential for optimal performance, and Apollo Client offers sophisticated query management features. It supports different fetching policies like cache-first, network-only, and cache-and-network, giving developers fine-grained control over when and how data is fetched or refreshed. Apollo Client can also batch multiple queries into a single network request to reduce overhead, and supports lazy queries that execute only on demand. These capabilities help minimize unnecessary data fetching, reduce network congestion, and optimize app responsiveness, particularly in complex applications with many interdependent queries.

7. Facilitates Secure Data Handling with Authentication Integration

Security is paramount when working with APIs and databases, and Apollo Client integrates smoothly with authentication mechanisms. By attaching tokens or credentials to GraphQL requests, it enables secure communication between the client and server. Apollo Client works with authentication flows such as OAuth, JWT, and cookie-based sessions, ensuring that users can only access data they’re authorized to see. This security integration is crucial for implementing role-based access controls and protecting sensitive database information, while still providing a seamless user experience.

8. Provides Robust Developer Tools for Debugging and Optimization

Apollo Client comes with a rich set of developer tools that simplify debugging and optimize performance. The Apollo Client Devtools browser extension allows developers to inspect active queries, mutations, and cache state in real-time. This visibility helps identify performance bottlenecks, understand cache behavior, and troubleshoot errors effectively. Additionally, Apollo’s detailed error handling and logging features provide valuable insights during development and testing. These tools accelerate the development cycle, improve code quality, and help maintain scalable and performant applications as they grow.

Example of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs Database Language

Apollo Client is widely used to bridge the gap between frontend applications and GraphQL APIs that communicate with databases like PostgreSQL, MySQL, or MongoDB. This example will demonstrate how Apollo Client can be integrated into a typical React application to fetch, display, and update data stored in a backend database via a GraphQL API.

1. Fetching Data with Apollo Client Query

import { useQuery, gql } from '@apollo/client';

const GET_USERS = gql`
  query GetUsers {
    users {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function UsersList() {
  const { loading, error, data } = useQuery(GET_USERS);

  if (loading) return <p>Loading users...</p>;
  if (error) return <p>Error: {error.message}</p>;

  return (
    <ul>
      {data.users.map(user => (
        <li key={user.id}>{user.name} - {user.email}</li>
      ))}
    </ul>
  );
}

This example shows how to fetch a list of users from a GraphQL API connected to a database. The useQuery hook sends the GET_USERS query to the server. Apollo Client automatically manages the loading and error states and caches the data. This makes it easy to display database records in the UI with minimal code.

2. Adding Data with Apollo Client Mutation

import { useMutation, gql } from '@apollo/client';
import { useState } from 'react';

const ADD_USER = gql`
  mutation AddUser($name: String!, $email: String!) {
    addUser(name: $name, email: $email) {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function AddUserForm() {
  const [name, setName] = useState('');
  const [email, setEmail] = useState('');
  const [addUser, { loading, error }] = useMutation(ADD_USER);

  const handleSubmit = async (e) => {
    e.preventDefault();
    await addUser({ variables: { name, email } });
  };

  return (
    <form onSubmit={handleSubmit}>
      <input value={name} onChange={e => setName(e.target.value)} placeholder="Name" required />
      <input value={email} onChange={e => setEmail(e.target.value)} placeholder="Email" required />
      <button type="submit" disabled={loading}>Add User</button>
      {error && <p>Error: {error.message}</p>}
    </form>
  );
}

Here, a mutation is used to add a new user to the database via the GraphQL API. Apollo Client’s useMutation hook handles sending the mutation request. The form captures input, and on submission, it calls the mutation with variables. The mutation response includes the new user’s data, which can be used to update the UI or cache.

3. Updating Cache After Mutation

const [addUser] = useMutation(ADD_USER, {
  update(cache, { data: { addUser } }) {
    const existingUsers = cache.readQuery({ query: GET_USERS });
    cache.writeQuery({
      query: GET_USERS,
      data: { users: [...existingUsers.users, addUser] },
    });
  }
});

Apollo Client lets you update the local cache manually after a mutation. This snippet shows how to add the newly created user to the cached list of users immediately, without needing to refetch from the server. This results in a more responsive UI and fewer network requests.

4. Using Variables for Dynamic Queries

const GET_USER_BY_ID = gql`
  query GetUserById($id: ID!) {
    user(id: $id) {
      id
      name
      email
    }
  }
`;

function UserDetail({ userId }) {
  const { loading, error, data } = useQuery(GET_USER_BY_ID, {
    variables: { id: userId }
  });

  if (loading) return <p>Loading user details...</p>;
  if (error) return <p>Error: {error.message}</p>;

  return (
    <div>
      <h2>{data.user.name}</h2>
      <p>{data.user.email}</p>
    </div>
  );
}

This example demonstrates how to use query variables to fetch specific data dynamically. The userId is passed as a variable to the GET_USER_BY_ID query. Apollo Client ensures the query updates when the variable changes, enabling flexible and reusable components that reflect the state of the backend database.

Advantages of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database

These are the Advantages of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database:

1. Simplified Data Management: Apollo Client provides a seamless way to fetch, cache, and manage data from GraphQL APIs. It abstracts complex networking logic, letting developers focus on building features instead of handling API calls. This simplification reduces boilerplate and improves productivity when connecting to databases. The built-in cache also ensures efficient data retrieval and updates without unnecessary network requests.
2. Powerful Caching Mechanism: Apollo Client’s normalized caching stores query results by unique identifiers, allowing fast access and automatic UI updates. This reduces redundant network calls and enhances app performance by reading from the cache whenever possible. The cache also supports offline functionality and optimistic UI, improving responsiveness and user experience.
3. Declarative and Reactive UI Integration: With Apollo Client hooks and components, data fetching and mutation become declarative and reactive. Developers can easily tie data to UI components in frameworks like React, enabling automatic updates when data changes. This leads to clean, maintainable code that reacts naturally to database updates via GraphQL.
4. Enhanced Developer Experience: Apollo Client offers powerful developer tools such as Apollo DevTools that help inspect queries, mutations, and cache state. These tools streamline debugging and performance tuning, accelerating development. Clear error handling and detailed logging further improve the developer workflow when working with GraphQL and databases.
5. Flexible Query and Mutation Handling: Apollo Client supports flexible fetching policies and variable-driven queries, making it easy to tailor data requests according to app needs. Features like query batching and lazy execution optimize network traffic. This flexibility allows smooth integration with complex backend database operations and dynamic user interactions.
6. Built-in Support for Real-Time Updates: Apollo Client supports GraphQL subscriptions, enabling real-time data synchronization with backend databases. This is essential for live features like notifications, chats, or dashboards. Subscriptions maintain open connections and push updates instantly to the UI, keeping the frontend always in sync with database changes.
7. Optimistic UI for Instant Feedback: Apollo Client enables optimistic UI updates, where the interface immediately reflects user actions before the server responds. This creates a smoother, faster user experience by reducing perceived latency. If the backend operation fails, Apollo automatically rolls back the changes, ensuring data consistency. This feature is especially useful when interacting with databases through GraphQL mutations.
8. Seamless Authentication and Authorization Integration: Apollo Client easily integrates with various authentication methods like JWT, OAuth, or cookie-based sessions. It allows attaching auth tokens to GraphQL requests, ensuring secure access to database-backed data. This makes enforcing role-based access control and protecting sensitive information straightforward, while maintaining a seamless user experience.
9. Cross-Platform Compatibility: Apollo Client is designed to work across different platforms and frameworks including React, Angular, Vue, React Native, and more. This flexibility makes it suitable for web, mobile, and desktop applications that interact with GraphQL APIs and databases. Developers can maintain consistent data management patterns regardless of the client environment.
10. Scalable Architecture for Growing Applications: Apollo Client’s modular and extensible architecture supports scaling from small projects to enterprise-grade applications. Features like query batching, fine-tuned cache control, and partial data fetching reduce server load and improve performance. This scalability ensures that applications can handle increasing data volume and user interactions without compromising speed or reliability.

Disadvantages of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database

These are the Disadvantages of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Databases:

1. Steep Learning Curve for Beginners: Apollo Client introduces several concepts such as cache normalization, query policies, and mutations that can be challenging for newcomers. Understanding how to properly configure and use these features takes time and practice. Beginners may find initial setup and debugging difficult, which can slow down development until they gain proficiency.
2. Increased Bundle Size: Integrating Apollo Client in frontend applications can significantly increase the JavaScript bundle size. This might affect the initial loading time, especially on slower networks or low-end devices. Although tree-shaking and code splitting help, the additional library size is a consideration for performance-sensitive projects.
3. Complexity of Cache Management: While Apollo’s caching is powerful, managing cache updates for complex applications can become complicated. Developers need to carefully handle cache writes, evictions, and invalidations to avoid stale or inconsistent UI states. This often requires writing custom update logic, which adds to the maintenance overhead.
4. Overhead for Simple Applications: For small or simple applications with minimal data requirements, Apollo Client can be overkill. The setup, configuration, and runtime overhead might not justify the benefits in such cases. Simpler alternatives or direct GraphQL requests may be more efficient and easier to manage.
5. Potential for Overfetching: Although GraphQL is designed to avoid overfetching, poorly constructed queries or inefficient cache policies in Apollo Client can lead to excessive data loading. If developers do not optimize queries or use caching correctly, it may increase network usage and degrade performance.
6. Reliance on GraphQL Server Implementation: Apollo Client depends heavily on the quality and capabilities of the backend GraphQL server. If the server is poorly designed or lacks proper schema definitions, client-side development and optimizations become challenging. This coupling can slow down frontend progress when backend APIs are unstable or incomplete.
7. Debugging Can Be Challenging: Although Apollo provides developer tools, debugging complex queries, cache issues, or subscription errors can still be time-consuming. Misconfigured fetch policies or unexpected cache behavior often lead to silent failures or stale UI states. Developers may spend extra time tracing the root cause of bugs that stem from cache or client-server sync issues.
8. Requires Schema Awareness: Apollo Client is tightly coupled with your GraphQL schema, meaning any backend schema changes must be reflected on the client. Without tools like code generation or type safety, developers risk query mismatches or runtime errors. Maintaining alignment between client queries and database-driven APIs becomes more difficult in large or frequently changing schemas.
9. Subscription Setup Is Complex: Real-time features via GraphQL subscriptions are powerful, but setting them up with Apollo Client can be complex. It often requires configuring WebSocket links, middleware, and custom logic for handling real-time data updates. This adds development and testing overhead, especially when interacting with database changes that need live sync.
10. Learning Curve for Advanced Features: Advanced Apollo features like pagination, optimistic UI, local state management, and custom cache strategies require deeper knowledge of the library. Implementing these effectively often involves a steep learning curve and detailed documentation review. Inexperienced teams may struggle to fully utilize these features without causing bugs or performance issues.

Future Development and Enhancement of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Database

Following are the Future Development and Enhancement of Using Apollo Client with GraphQL APIs and Databases:

1. Improved Developer Experience with Smarter Tooling: Future versions of Apollo Client aim to enhance developer productivity with smarter and more intuitive tools. This includes better auto-completion, advanced schema introspection, and integration with modern editors. These improvements will help reduce errors, accelerate development, and make debugging easier when working with APIs and databases.
2. Enhanced Cache Automation and Flexibility: Apollo Client is expected to introduce more intelligent and automatic cache handling capabilities. This includes improved garbage collection, conflict resolution, and context-aware cache invalidation. Such features will reduce manual cache management and make it easier to maintain data consistency in apps with large and complex databases.
3. Native Support for Offline-First Applications: Future versions may bring more robust offline support, allowing developers to build fully offline-capable apps. This involves background sync, persistent caching, and automatic conflict resolution between local and remote data. This is especially beneficial for mobile apps that rely on database-backed GraphQL APIs but need to work without connectivity.
4. Better Integration with TypeScript and Code Generation: Apollo’s roadmap includes tighter TypeScript integration and improved support for tools like GraphQL Code Generator. This will enable strongly typed queries and mutations, reducing runtime errors and improving code maintainability. As GraphQL APIs and databases evolve, typed client interactions will enhance safety and clarity.
5. Simplified Real-Time Data Handling: Handling real-time updates via subscriptions is expected to become more streamlined. Apollo is working on simplifying subscription setup, reconnection handling, and event-driven UI updates. These enhancements will make it easier to build features like live dashboards, collaborative tools, and real-time analytics powered by database changes.
6. Broader Compatibility with Backend Architectures: Apollo Client will likely continue evolving to support a wider range of backend services and data sources. This includes serverless functions, microservices, and hybrid database environments. These improvements will make Apollo more versatile and adaptable in modern distributed system architectures.
7. Improved Local State Management: Apollo Client is also focusing on making local state management more intuitive and powerful. This includes unified handling of local and remote data with a cleaner API. Developers will be able to use Apollo as a one-stop state management solution, reducing the need for external libraries like Redux or Zustand.
8. Increased Performance Optimization: Future versions will optimize memory usage, network traffic, and UI rendering efficiency. Performance-focused improvements will help apps scale better, particularly those with heavy database queries or high user traffic. Features like automatic batching, caching strategies, and lazy loading will continue to evolve for better speed.
9. Seamless Multi-Database Support via Federated Schemas: As organizations increasingly use multiple databases, Apollo Client is expected to offer smoother support for federated GraphQL schemas. This will allow seamless querying across different backends like PostgreSQL, MongoDB, and MySQL without requiring separate queries or clients. Enhanced federation will simplify access to distributed data and improve the client’s ability to unify responses from various sources.
10. Advanced Monitoring and Analytics Integration: Future enhancements may include built-in support for analytics, query tracing, and usage monitoring within Apollo Client. These insights will help developers understand how their client interacts with the GraphQL API and the underlying databases. With better visibility into query performance and user behavior, teams can optimize database usage and enhance the overall user experience more effectively.